Skip to main content

HARESH SAYS: Courteous doctors can ease budget cuts pain

As published in Malay Mail today

Soo Siew Lan, 76, dances with staff Khairiah Mad Hassan during a fun therapy session at Kuala Lumpur Hospital on Monday. Medical staff should comfort patients despite budget cuts. - Picture by Hari Anggara (Malay Mail)

By Haresh Deol

I BECAME a father on Oct 24.

Having been by my wife’s side every step of the way, we were blessed with our bundle of joy, a baby boy, just days before Deepavali. 

Our journey to parenthood was made easy thanks to one man — Datuk Dr Alex Mathews.

A well-known figure in the fraternity and beyond, the former Obstetrical and Gynaecological Society of Malaysia president (1993/1994) comforted us every step of the way through his fatherly-like approach. 

The well-groomed tie-wearing doctor, who could pass off as a headmaster, has a keen interest in sports. Having served the government for many years, his experience and wisdom are evident not only through his greyish hair but from his choice of words (and intonation), reassuring patients they are in good hands.

I, had on our first visit to his clinic, asked if it was fine for Mrs to join me on a ride to Koh Lanta, Thailand. I promised we would stop at many places along the way to break the 800km-odd journey to which Dr Mathews replied: “There is no scientific evidence to prove long rides during such an early stage of pregnancy would cause harm. But as a father, I would say ‘no’.”

We drove to Kuantan for a short break instead.

A religious man, Dr Mathews (pic) treated everyone with respect, especially the nurses. Even medical representatives of pharmaceutical companies hold him in high regard.

However, not all of us have had pleasant encounters with doctors and medical staff.

Malay Mail reader Ramesh Singh, had on Oct 21, vented his frustration after his father-in-law was asked by a doctor in Selayang Hospital to hand-deliver his blood sample to a private laboratory.

“My 75-year-old father-in-law needed a cancer marker test before his CT scan. When they drew the blood, they passed it to my wife, who had to deliver the sample and was charged RM136.60 for it,” he said.

“She then had to pick up the results and only then could my father-in-law get the CT scan done. This is shameful, how are we taking care of our people if things like this cannot be sorted out?” 

It is dumbfounding for a doctor to ask a patient to send his blood sample to an independent laboratory instead of the hospital arranging to do this. Delay in the transportation of blood samples to the laboratory may cause alteration in test results.

What if a patient decides to park his car under the sun with his blood sample in his glove compartment to enjoy banana leaf rice before heading to the laboratory? What about the poor and disabled who either cannot afford such tests or are unable to travel from one corner to another? 

Ramesh’s nightmare did not end there.

His father-in-law, who hails from Taiping and travels to Kuala Lumpur for his routine check-ups, returned to the hospital for another appointment last Wednesday only to be told his 24-hour urine sample test was not carried out despite giving his sample on Oct 18.

The doctor instead referred to a test result taken last month, much to the chagrin of the patient. 

When Ramesh asked if the ministry was facing shortage of funds and they were incapable to carry out such tests, the nephrologist nodded her head and replied: “Go ask (Prime Minister Datuk Seri) Najib (Razak).”

Some may argue it is unfair to compare private and government medical staff. You pay for good service, they say. But I beg to differ. There are those in the private service who are not fit to be doctors or nurses. And there are government medical personnel who serve with plenty of zest. 

Medical staff have an obligation to serve all patients — rich or poor. Doctors, in the private or government sector, must uphold the sacred Hippocratic Oath.

Frustrated doctors should voice their grouses to their superiors instead of turning patients into punching bags or adopting a tidak apa approach. Doctors who climb the ladder and become managers must address grouses by their fellow doctors and not turn into politicians.

Some claim doctors are doing more paperwork than attending to patients, and that the doctor-patient ratio at government hospitals is ridiculous. 

Others say they are frustrated with budget cuts as they are unable to comprehensively examine  patients.
A circular from a government hospital revealed among the tests axed since last month were torch serology/toxoplasma, rubella and herpes, repeated tests for patients reactive for HIV, Hepatitis B and Hepatitis C, stool for rotavirus antigen and haemoglobin analysis.

“Government doctors are overwhelmed and not appreciated so some of them take it out on patients. I am not surprised that many doctors and patients at Selayang Hospital are frustrated that many tests had to be scrapped because of budget cuts,” said a medical representative from a pharmaceutical company.

“The budget cuts have opened the doors for China products that have no clinical evidence into our hospitals. These products are sourced from China and packed locally,” a manager of an international medical 
company added.

But a doctor had this to say: “Budget cuts or not, a doctor is a doctor … regardless government or private, he or she should treat all patients with respect and explain their health situation to them. Patients are already sick and need reassurance, not to be further agonised.”

He said hospital authorities must find ways to deal with the budget cuts and train their doctors to comfort patients, especially the elderly and the poor, so that their well-being is not compromised.

If the authorities can set aside their egos, perhaps they can learn from the likes of Dr Mathews and his contemporaries on ethics and establishing a healthy doctor-patient relationship.

The ministry should be mindful about the woes faced by the public and the government must realise healthcare is one sector that can never be compromised. 

While the policy makers continue their battle to improve healthcare services, doctors can help ease the pain by injecting courtesy while treating the sick. The right words can make a lot of difference. 

Doctors, and medical staff in general, ought to realise such good traits will go a long way.

HARESH is executive editor of Malay Mail. He can be reached at or on Twitter @HareshDeol


Popular posts from this blog

Football journo's accreditation card retracted for being 'overly critical'

Four Four Two journalist Vijhay Vick's accreditation card to cover the M-League has been "retracted" by Football Malaysia LLP last night.

The letter, signed by FMLLP chief executive officer Kevin Ramalingam, stated:
"We are open to criticism by the public, however, it has been brought to FMLLP's attention that you have been overly critical of the Malaysian League and have made misleading statements and or shared misleading statements made by third parties. This is very damaging to the image of the League and the brand that we are trying to build."
It remains unclear which articles written by Vijhay are said to be "overly critical" of the Malaysian League.
Vijhay, in responding to the letter he received last night, said: 
"I was shocked (to receive the letter). I would like to know which articles of mine that are overly critical of the league."
It is best if FMLLP explained its definition of being "overly critical". 
While the bo…

Poser over national table tennis association 'RM8 million loans' to private companies

UPDATE (May 20, 2018; 3.15pm):Lawyer representing Table Tennis Association of Malaysia admitted manner in which loans amounting to RM8 million given out by association to two developers was "not right" and that his client is taking steps to terminate the contracts. He said this after attending an exco meeting at the association's office in Bukit Jalil this morning.

The Table Tennis Association of Malaysia (TTAM) has been smashed with allegations of giving out RM8 million worth of "loans" to two developers, raising eyebrows and irking at least two of its affiliates.

A police report has also been lodged over the matter.

According to a letter by the Kuala Lumpur Table Tennis Association (KLTTA), written on May 3:

i. TTAM's Financial Statement (ended March 31, 2018) presented during the 6th Exco Meeting on April 21, 2018 saw a total sum of RM8 million loans granted to two private companies - Ekal Jaya Sdn Bhd and Iktimewah Sdn Bhd (RM4 million …

So what's next for FAM?

UPDATE (March 25, 3.15pm): Tunku Ismail Ibrahim resigns as FA of Malaysia president.
UPDATE (March 17, 9.52am): As of late last night, it's status quo at Wisma FAM.
Tunku Ismail Ibrahim remains as president as "no resignation letter was submitted".
Insiders say Tunku Ismail was "very disturbed and feels unappreciated following critical comments, especially on social media, about the national team's FIFA ranking despite the many other achievements (as listed in the original post below) throughout his close to one year stint in office".
UPDATE (March 16, 8.25am): FA of Malaysia general-secretary Datuk Hamidin Amin said: 
"Sudah tentu jika kita membiarkan Tunku Ismail meletak jawatan, kita juga akan kehilangan penaja dan saya sendiri tidak dapat membayangkan siapa yang layak untuk menggantikan tempat baginda sebagai Presiden FAM."
Read his full statement here.


UPDATE (March 16, 10.19am): Another FAM official makes a (very short) statement. Below…