Skip to main content

Selangor FA Shah Alam Stadium saga evident politics, egos bigger than football

UPDATE 12.44pm: Here is the podcast of the show 'Pressing Matters' that I was on this morning.



I will be on BFM this morning (9.30am) to speak about the stand off between Selangor FA and the state government.

For those in the dark over the nauseating episode (or those who lost track on how the whole fiasco started), here's my 'Selangor FA v State Government Saga for Dummies':

Main actors:
i. Datuk Seri Azmin Ali (Selangor Menteri Besar & PKR deputy president)
ii. Datuk Seri Subahan Kamal (Selangor FA president, was vice president when Azmin was Selangor FA president, Umno man, former state assemblyman for Taman Templer and now a businessman)

Supporting actors:
i. Amirudin Shari (Selangor Youth, Culture and Entrepreneur Development Committee chairman)
ii. Rosman Ibrahim (Selangor FA general secretary)
iii. Datuk S. Sivasundram (Selangor FA treasurer)

Azmin quits as Selangor FA president in December 2016, claiming among others:
i. FAS executive council is bogged by 'excessive politics.
ii. FAS adopts the old-fashioned way of doing things. 
iii. And the team is overly dependent on subsidies.

Can't argue with him there.

And since he quit, Selangor FA has not received funding from the state government and has not allowed to play at the Shah Alam Stadium which is owned by the Shah Alam City Council (MBSA). For the record, Selangor FA have made the KL Stadium in Cheras their home ground this season.

But here's the thing ....

Those within FAS claim Azmin and his boys were not transparent in their efforts to privatise Selangor football.

They also demanded to know why Azmin wanted to get rid of Rosman and Sivasundram and sacked former coach Zainal Abidin Hassan without proper notice.

FAS, in a statement on its website, wrote:

"Bagaimana pula dengan isu pemecatan Ketua Jurulatih (Zainal Abidin Hassan) yang tidak mengikut prosidur dan melalui kenyataan dari Facebook sahaja dan FAS perlu menanggung bayaran pampasan kepada beliau?
"Hampir terlupa pula isu penubuhan Red Giants Sdn Bhd di mana Lembaga Pengarah nya adalah Amirudin dan sahabat karibnya."
The statement on the website was in response to Amirudin's statement on why the state government denied Selangor FA the right to play at Shah Alam Stadium. It was reported:
" ... kemelut dalaman FAS bermula apabila segelintir daripada kepimpinan di dalam FAS menentang perubahan yang cuba dibawa oleh Presiden FAS ketika itu, iaitu Y.A.B Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin Ali, juga merupakan Menteri Besar Selangor.
Dalam satu mesyuarat, sebahagian daripada ahli kepimpinan FAS yang diketuai oleh Datuk Seri Subahan Kamal dikatakan mendesak Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin untuk menarik balik arahan pemberhentian Setiausaha Agung FAS, Rosman Ibrahim dan juga Bendahari FAS, Datuk S Sivasundram yang masing-masing menyandang jawatan tersebut pada ketika itu.
Walaupun dijelaskan perkara tersebut akan diperbincangkan pada agenda seterusnya menurut urutan minit mesyuarat, kumpulan yang membantah ini bertindak keluar daripada mesyuarat yang dipengerusikan sendiri oleh Presiden FAS.
Tindakan tersebut dianggap sebagai biadap dan tidak sepatutnya berlaku, mengambil kira kapasiti Y.A.B Dato’ Seri Mohamed Azmin Ali sebagai Menteri Besar kepada Kerajaan Negeri Selangor yang telah memberikan sepenuh sokongan terhadap FAS sehingga mampu merangkul kejuaraan Piala Malaysia pada 2015.
Disebabkan tindakan yang dianggap mencabar kedudukan Kerajaan Negeri dan angkuh kerana mengendahkan peraturan mesyuarat rasmi, Dato’ Pegawai Kewangan Negeri yang turut menghadiri mesyuarat tersebut mencadangkan agar segala kemudahan yang dinikmati oleh FAS ditarik balik serta merta."

Like a Bollywood movie right? Let's take a short commercial break.

The state government's official portal  had once reported:
Beliau (Azmin) turut menyokong pelantikan Naib Presiden FAS, Datuk Subahan Kamal sebagai Pengurus Selangor kerana bekas Pengurus Harimau Malaya itu seorang berpengalaman luas dalam bola sepak negeri dan negara.
“Dalam bola sepak, kita kena buang sentimen politik. Sama seperti Tan Sri Annuar Musa untuk Kelantan, kita lihat pasukan The Red Warriors terus maju dan berjaya.
“Subahan sebagai anak jati Selangor, faham selok-belok bola sepak negeri dan mampu membimbing Selangor ke arah kejayaan.”
Note: PAS promised a new football stadium in Kelantan if they won GE13. The party retained its power in the east coast state but the new stadium is no where to be seen.
Now, back to the saga.

Following this ugly episode, Football Malaysia LLP is looking at ensuring teams confirm their venues SIX months before the M-League begins, as I tweeted on Saturday night.

My observation about this drama?

i. Privatisation is the way forward. But Azmin must explain how Red Giants Sdn Bhd came about and the people behind the company. 

ii. I still can't believe Azmin's government gave Selangor FA RM23 million for the 2016 season. Saari Sungib asked FAS how the money was spent (which is valid) but my question is why did Azmin even give that much of money to the state football team? Were other sports ie Selangor Badminton Association, Selangor Swimming Association allocated with such generous funds (which is highly unlikely despite Malaysian shuttlers and swimmers have a brighter chance of participating in the Olympics compared to our footballers)? The money could have been better spent on fixing potholes (remember how a motorcyclist died after entering a pothole in Klang?) Wasn't Tan Sri Khalid Ibrahim forced out as Selangor Menteri Besar due to potholes and garbage collection issues, among others. Hmm....

iii. Let's say Selangor spends RM9 million on wages alone this season. This is not factoring other expenses including transport, accommodation and food for the players and officials. A team will play a bare minimum of 15 home matches this season - 11 league matches, three Malaysia Cup matches and 1 FA Cup match. 

So RM9 million / 15 home matches = RM600,000 (spent per home match)

The ticket prices for the upcoming Selangor v Pahang match are as below:

So let's say the ticket price (Open) is RM15, GST is 90sen and the remaining RM2.70 is set aside for the respective fees (total RM18.60).

And from the RM15, at least RM5 will be set aside for levy, security etc. That means Selangor FA pockets RM10 per home ticket. Lebih kurang lah.

So RM600,000 / RM10 = 60,000 tickets - that's the number of tickets per home match, on average, Selangor FA has to sell just to pay wages. 

Getting 10,000 supporters to fill the stands at every home match is already a bonus, given the late kick off (at 9pm). Can Selangor FA pull it off? I'm sure they thought about this before signing up their new players.

Selangor FA should have just opted for KL Stadium in Cheras from the start instead of trying to play "tarik tali" with the state government. And if Azmin remains in power after GE14, then Subahan and Company will need to completely forget about securing funds from the state.

Another commercial break

Azmin has blocked me on Twitter - for reasons best known to him.

Okay, now back to the story ...

If Azmin truly believes that "Dalam bola sepak, kita kena buang sentimen politik" then he should at least meet Subahan whom he described as "... anak jati Selangor, faham selok-belok bola sepak negeri dan mampu membimbing Selangor ke arah kejayaan.”

As for the money, well Selangor FA can't go around calling themselves the Red Giants if they cannot even sort their finances out and do not have their OWN home ground (Remember, Shah Alam Stadium DOES NOT belong to Selangor FA).

As for Subahan, he should know how shallow politics is in this country. I know of politicians who cringe or don't attend wedding or social receptions if an opposition member is invited for the same do. I'm sure he knows of this too.

Well politics have no place in sports but it's evident in Selangor that members from two clashing parties can't sit at the same table. If the way forward for Selangor FA is by Subahan quitting, then so be it. 

If these individuals claim it is not about politics, then please explain to the fans what this is all about.

Moral of the story?

A shameful affair that shows politics and egos are bigger than football. The same can happen to other state teams as well. It's important teams start standing on their own feet and not rely on state funds anymore.


  1. 1st. I verily believes its not a game between Azmin vs Subahan but kinda conspiracy planned by Amirudin to topple & to force Rosman and Sundra as well to step down.

    2nd. Once Rosman & Sundra step down, Amirudin will ask the President to appoint "their" proxies to step in. (FASs' consti rules that only President can appoint candidates for those post.) The main reason of planning so is to enable "their" team to take over or to hijack the administration of FAS.

    3rd. FAS did put up a special ad hoc committee in mid 2016 to handle the privatisation plan for teams under FAS i.e M League team, President Cuppers and Youth Cuppers as well. Outcome was conveyed to Amirudin to get approval from Azmin but no replies were received. Its either the messages were not being made known to Azmin or Azmin/Amirudin were unhappy.with it. No one knows what happen to the proposal.

    4th. To make matter worst, the said RM23mills were never bank in to FASs' acc but vide MSNS payroll. Infact, it were only till August 2016 thus an amount of RM13.8mills were released (priorities were for team's salary)

    5th. Rosman & Sundra took a long leaves to avoid further hassle in the office. Both of them wrote a letter to the President (Azmin) offering, I repeat, offering their resignations should they were the roots of the fiasco. But Amirudin read it as they were tendering their resignations. Thus, Azmin announced it in a clear note-We accept your resignation.

    6th. Then come the issue of no where, the existance of Red Giants Sdn Bhd to take charge of the privatisation issue.

    7th. During the FAS executive committee, Subahan raised the issue of the status of Rosman & Sundra. Are they still the Secretary & Tressurer or what because they never resign. And even if they do so, it must be the 1st agenda to be discuss in the exco meeting as the FASs' consti say so. But Azmin was reluctant but insist to proceed about the being of the privatisation agenda (as Red Giants Sdn Bd is at stake)

    8th. This was the main issue that triggered the heated discussion. Azmin seems like dont know anything about the association's (FAS) consti on about the priority of the main secretariat post and was wrongly advised by Amirudin on the "offering to resign" and tendering resignations clarification.

    9th. Till todate, Azmin and Amirudin are reluctant to discuss anything as this will prove their ignorance of the FAS constitution. Thus, in my opinion, the only way for Azmin & Amirudin to hide their embarrassment is to neglect the actual fact and pretend that they are always right.


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Football journo's accreditation card retracted for being 'overly critical'

Four Four Two journalist Vijhay Vick's accreditation card to cover the M-League has been "retracted" by Football Malaysia LLP last night.

The letter, signed by FMLLP chief executive officer Kevin Ramalingam, stated:
"We are open to criticism by the public, however, it has been brought to FMLLP's attention that you have been overly critical of the Malaysian League and have made misleading statements and or shared misleading statements made by third parties. This is very damaging to the image of the League and the brand that we are trying to build."
It remains unclear which articles written by Vijhay are said to be "overly critical" of the Malaysian League.
Vijhay, in responding to the letter he received last night, said: 
"I was shocked (to receive the letter). I would like to know which articles of mine that are overly critical of the league."
It is best if FMLLP explained its definition of being "overly critical". 
While the bo…

Poser over national table tennis association 'RM8 million loans' to private companies

UPDATE (May 20, 2018; 3.15pm):Lawyer representing Table Tennis Association of Malaysia admitted manner in which loans amounting to RM8 million given out by association to two developers was "not right" and that his client is taking steps to terminate the contracts. He said this after attending an exco meeting at the association's office in Bukit Jalil this morning.

The Table Tennis Association of Malaysia (TTAM) has been smashed with allegations of giving out RM8 million worth of "loans" to two developers, raising eyebrows and irking at least two of its affiliates.

A police report has also been lodged over the matter.

According to a letter by the Kuala Lumpur Table Tennis Association (KLTTA), written on May 3:

i. TTAM's Financial Statement (ended March 31, 2018) presented during the 6th Exco Meeting on April 21, 2018 saw a total sum of RM8 million loans granted to two private companies - Ekal Jaya Sdn Bhd and Iktimewah Sdn Bhd (RM4 million …

So what's next for FAM?

UPDATE (March 25, 3.15pm): Tunku Ismail Ibrahim resigns as FA of Malaysia president.
UPDATE (March 17, 9.52am): As of late last night, it's status quo at Wisma FAM.
Tunku Ismail Ibrahim remains as president as "no resignation letter was submitted".
Insiders say Tunku Ismail was "very disturbed and feels unappreciated following critical comments, especially on social media, about the national team's FIFA ranking despite the many other achievements (as listed in the original post below) throughout his close to one year stint in office".
UPDATE (March 16, 8.25am): FA of Malaysia general-secretary Datuk Hamidin Amin said: 
"Sudah tentu jika kita membiarkan Tunku Ismail meletak jawatan, kita juga akan kehilangan penaja dan saya sendiri tidak dapat membayangkan siapa yang layak untuk menggantikan tempat baginda sebagai Presiden FAM."
Read his full statement here.


UPDATE (March 16, 10.19am): Another FAM official makes a (very short) statement. Below…