Sports Development Act toothless legislation?



The Attorney-General's Chambers has declared a NFA (No Further Action) on the investigation papers (IP) into the failure of Klang City International Marathon organiser to obtain a licence or apply for one from the Sports Commissioner to hold the event last December.

 The NST quoted Klang Selatan district police chief Assistant Commissioner Shamsul Amar Ramli as saying: "The order was done on the directive of the Attorney-General with the reason that Section 36(1) of the Sports Development Act 1997 is not an offence that can be accusable and it was subsequently classified NFA," 

 Read the full report here.

 Let's dissect the quote.

 " ... with the reason that Section 36(1) of the Sports Development Act 1997 is not an offence that can be accusable." 

 The AGC may have come to that conclusion because Section 36 does not specify that not having the appropriate license is an offence. 

 But ....

 Section 39 of the Sports Development Act reads:


Lawyer Datuk Seri Jahaberdeen Mohamed Yunoos, who is also the Kuala Lumpur Badminton Association president, said:

 "Section 39 of the Sports Development Act 1997 clearly allocates a penal action for an offence committed under Section 36(1) of the same Act.

 "If Section 39 is not given its proper effect, than the so-called offences in the Sports Development Act becomes not actionable and therefore the Sports Development Act is of no use at all to regulate sporting events in Malaysia."

 Youth and Sports Minister Khairy Jamaluddin was quoted by NST on Dec 11, 2017 as saying: “Failure to get a licence from the Sports Commissioner’s Office is a breach of Section 36 of the Sports Development Act 1997.
“It is only right for the organiser to be investigated by the police and charged in court for breaking the law."
Read the full report here.
There are specific provisions in the Act that provide for penalty (eg Section 30 and Section 38) but if no penalty is expressly provided, then Section 39 should rightfully come into play.

Now let's look at what the Sports Development Act 1997 is all about.


Key words: "administration of sports" and "matters incidental thereto".

 Injuries can happen during sporting events. Thus the issue of responsibility comes into play. 

 And this is where the Sports Development Act should rightfully play its role to ensure those wanting to organise events are regulated and licensed.

 For the record, the Youth and Sports Ministry spoke about plans to amend the Sports Development Act in 2015 and said the same thing again in 2017.

 Would this now mean:

 1. Organisers no longer need to seek approval from the Sports Commissioner's Office?
2. The role of the Sports Commissioner is now redundant? And as such, would tax payers' money be better spent elsewhere instead of paying the wages of the staff and maintaining the office?
3. National federations/associations will no longer have any say in the running of sporting events in the country?
4. The Sports Development Act 1997 is a toothless legislation?

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

From 'Mr P' to 'Kemelut Dalaman BAM': Four chapters of 'mesej Whatsapp layang'

Image
Surat layang , or rather ' mesej Whatsapp (or some will pronounce as Wasup) layang '. That was what I received this afternoon from a number that is not registered on my phone. The sender identified him/herself as " ahli yg memerhati tingkah laku BAM " (Badminton Association of Malaysia). The four chapters were titled as:  'Siapa dia Tan Sri BAM "Mr P"' Perletakan Jawatan Presiden BAM 'Siapa Tengku Zafrul' Kemelut Dalaman BAM There were many allegations to which the sender justified as not " fitnah " but " hakikat apa yg berlaku ". The four chapters highlights Mr P's "connection kuat ", goes into why Tengku Zafrul was named as the incoming BAM president, and takes issue with the establishment of 'Yayasan Badminton Nasional' and Akademi Badminton Malaysia. The writer (unsure if the sender is also the writer) also wrote that ' majority in the Council dalam BAM semua tak berani buat laporan sebab tak
Read more

Pelepasan cukai tambahan untuk pembelian alatan sukan, sewaan fasiliti sukan antara cadangan untuk Bajet 2024

Image
Berikut merupakan antara cadangan-cadangan Kementerian Belia dan Sukan untuk Bajet 2024 yang akan dibentangkan bulan hadapan. 1. Pengasingan sukan daripada kategori gaya hidup 2. Meneruskan dan memperluaskan inisiatif pelepasan cukai tambahan bagi aktiviti sukan berdasarkan senarai baharu 103 sukan berkuatkuasa Mac 2023 seperti berikut: 3. Pelepasan cukai tambahan sebanyak RM5,000 khusus berkaitan dengan aktiviti sukan yang dibelanjakan oleh individu bagi: • pembelian peralatan sukan untuk aktiviti sukan mengikut Akta Pembangunan Sukan 1997. • bayaran sewaan atau fi kemasukan ke mana-mana fasiliti sukan. • bayaran fi pendaftaran bagi penyertaan pertandingan sukan yang diluluskan di bawah Akta Pembangunan Sukan 1997. • Bayaran jurulatih/latihan/kelas untuk aktiviti sukan mengikut Akta Pembangunan Sukan 1997. Justifikasi: Impak kepada negara 1. Pembudayaan gaya hidup sihat dan aktif melalui aktiviti bersukan kepada semua peringkat sebagai pelaburan  kepada negara bagi mengurangkan beban
Read more

Ramlan saga - Part 3

UPDATE (May 23, 2012: 12.06pm): Dilema JKR, 'dua' ketua pengarah - this was brought to my attention. Read here for more. ----- I first wrote about the effort to remove National Sports Institute director general Dr Ramlan Aziz in March - as seen here . Then I wrote about the same subject again early May . I was invited to be a guest for this week's Kafe Sukan but had to decline as the recording was done on Sunday - the same day I left the country. Apparently Ramlan's predicament was discussed. Despite receiving numerous SMS-es - for and against what was discussed - I will refrain from commenting as I have yet to view the show. I have also been told there are efforts to get certain people to replace Ramlan. To me that is secondary. I have still not obtained the answers to these questions; 1. According to the NSI Act, only the minister can hire or fire the director general. Has the minister issued such a directive? 2. According to the country's Lab
Read more